真愛無國界 那家人呢? - 異國戀

By George
at 2010-04-12T13:03
at 2010-04-12T13:03
Table of Contents
我想我來分享一下我的經驗好了。
不是我談戀愛的經驗(羞)。
是我對待他人感情的方法。
******
先說,我是一個臨床社工和健康心理學家。
我的工作就是幫助別人釐清他們對於自己與他人的關係。
我們入行的基礎守則:
請把你對於他人關係的先入為主的意見(也就是成見或偏見)放在一邊,
先好好地聽他們怎麼說。
這入行守則聽起來與講起來非常容易,
但事實上,卻是最困難的。
很多時候,連我這個入行超過十年的老鳥也還是會犯這個錯--
就是讓你先入為主的成見去汙染你對於他人的真誠理解。
坦白說,人有先入為主的成見是非常自然的,
已經很多研究証實這點。
但,這並不代表人的成見具道德上的善,或在決策上是有效的(efficient)。
更甚者,這些成見或偏見,往往助長或維持了某些族群的汙名與歧視。
這,並不是我們會想要的。
於是,去仔細聆聽他人對於關係的處理或選擇,
並先把你的成見丟在一邊 -- 這在當你想去理解不符合你文化預設的人的時候尤為重要。
*******
好了,講這些入行守則,就是要回應來你下面這段負面經驗。
: 最後一位 是個高才生 但是我也最瞧不起她
: C女 家裡環境優渥 身為長女 又受高等精英教育 考上最高學府法律系也是正常
: 畢業後留學英國 由於天資聰穎 當然就是好學校
: C女沒有台灣的感情糾葛 (應該是沒有啦~不過也不確定...)
: 於是在英國交往一個紳士 土生土長的中國裔英國人
: 不過 在讀了碩士 博士後
: C女便決定留在英國 不回台灣了
: 兩老不開心 甚至有點難過
: 因為C女秉持著 真愛最偉大 的真理
: 決定畢業前立即下嫁 並取得英國藉
: 舉行婚禮時 兩老無奈 所以不參加 派了C女的大妹參加
: 聽完這個故事後 我只覺得父母親努力栽培好像丟到馬桶
: 而為了自己的真愛 也不管父母親聽不聽的懂英文 更不管兩老在台灣孤單
: 這樣的博士 這樣的真愛 挺諷刺的吧
坦白說,光看你這一段的敘述,
我真的不知道這如何能夠成你「瞧不起」這位女性的理由。
因為這位女性不孝嗎?
因為這位女性為了「真愛」而拋棄了「家人」嗎?
是不是因為這位女性的關係選擇不符合你對於孝順的要求??
但,
我想問你:
請問你真的去完整理解過他家庭的動力嗎?
你真的知道這位女性在做決策時每一個細微的考量與步驟嗎?
另外,這位女性嫁的是華裔。那麼:
她的情況跟一個普通家庭反對女兒婚事或不喜歡她的男友又有甚麼不一樣?
問你的這三個問題,我知道,很簡單,但卻也都是很難回答的問題。
很多時後當事人也尚未能釐清,更何況我們這些「外人」?
所以,我想我們能夠做的,
並不是去「論斷」他人的關係,
而是在他人需要的時候,去提供同理與傾聽。
******
或許,我下篇文章應該要來寫一些我以前助人的案例。
(當然,把當事人的資料寫出來是不被允許的,但是,把一些片段綜合起來卻
是可以的。)
看看能不能讓大家知道,原來人類的關係,是如此地複雜與微妙,
而非用道德與文化要求能夠去限制的,進而能夠更體貼地去面對他人對於關係的處理....
--
不是我談戀愛的經驗(羞)。
是我對待他人感情的方法。
******
先說,我是一個臨床社工和健康心理學家。
我的工作就是幫助別人釐清他們對於自己與他人的關係。
我們入行的基礎守則:
請把你對於他人關係的先入為主的意見(也就是成見或偏見)放在一邊,
先好好地聽他們怎麼說。
這入行守則聽起來與講起來非常容易,
但事實上,卻是最困難的。
很多時候,連我這個入行超過十年的老鳥也還是會犯這個錯--
就是讓你先入為主的成見去汙染你對於他人的真誠理解。
坦白說,人有先入為主的成見是非常自然的,
已經很多研究証實這點。
但,這並不代表人的成見具道德上的善,或在決策上是有效的(efficient)。
更甚者,這些成見或偏見,往往助長或維持了某些族群的汙名與歧視。
這,並不是我們會想要的。
於是,去仔細聆聽他人對於關係的處理或選擇,
並先把你的成見丟在一邊 -- 這在當你想去理解不符合你文化預設的人的時候尤為重要。
*******
好了,講這些入行守則,就是要回應來你下面這段負面經驗。
: 最後一位 是個高才生 但是我也最瞧不起她
: C女 家裡環境優渥 身為長女 又受高等精英教育 考上最高學府法律系也是正常
: 畢業後留學英國 由於天資聰穎 當然就是好學校
: C女沒有台灣的感情糾葛 (應該是沒有啦~不過也不確定...)
: 於是在英國交往一個紳士 土生土長的中國裔英國人
: 不過 在讀了碩士 博士後
: C女便決定留在英國 不回台灣了
: 兩老不開心 甚至有點難過
: 因為C女秉持著 真愛最偉大 的真理
: 決定畢業前立即下嫁 並取得英國藉
: 舉行婚禮時 兩老無奈 所以不參加 派了C女的大妹參加
: 聽完這個故事後 我只覺得父母親努力栽培好像丟到馬桶
: 而為了自己的真愛 也不管父母親聽不聽的懂英文 更不管兩老在台灣孤單
: 這樣的博士 這樣的真愛 挺諷刺的吧
坦白說,光看你這一段的敘述,
我真的不知道這如何能夠成你「瞧不起」這位女性的理由。
因為這位女性不孝嗎?
因為這位女性為了「真愛」而拋棄了「家人」嗎?
是不是因為這位女性的關係選擇不符合你對於孝順的要求??
但,
我想問你:
請問你真的去完整理解過他家庭的動力嗎?
你真的知道這位女性在做決策時每一個細微的考量與步驟嗎?
另外,這位女性嫁的是華裔。那麼:
她的情況跟一個普通家庭反對女兒婚事或不喜歡她的男友又有甚麼不一樣?
問你的這三個問題,我知道,很簡單,但卻也都是很難回答的問題。
很多時後當事人也尚未能釐清,更何況我們這些「外人」?
所以,我想我們能夠做的,
並不是去「論斷」他人的關係,
而是在他人需要的時候,去提供同理與傾聽。
******
或許,我下篇文章應該要來寫一些我以前助人的案例。
(當然,把當事人的資料寫出來是不被允許的,但是,把一些片段綜合起來卻
是可以的。)
看看能不能讓大家知道,原來人類的關係,是如此地複雜與微妙,
而非用道德與文化要求能夠去限制的,進而能夠更體貼地去面對他人對於關係的處理....
--
Tags:
異國戀
All Comments

By Barb Cronin
at 2010-04-15T14:02
at 2010-04-15T14:02

By Oscar
at 2010-04-19T17:37
at 2010-04-19T17:37

By Catherine
at 2010-04-24T17:02
at 2010-04-24T17:02

By Zenobia
at 2010-04-27T19:16
at 2010-04-27T19:16

By Queena
at 2010-04-29T06:23
at 2010-04-29T06:23

By Agnes
at 2010-05-03T13:30
at 2010-05-03T13:30

By Catherine
at 2010-05-08T00:43
at 2010-05-08T00:43

By Noah
at 2010-05-12T17:19
at 2010-05-12T17:19

By Connor
at 2010-05-14T02:20
at 2010-05-14T02:20

By Kyle
at 2010-05-17T20:01
at 2010-05-17T20:01

By Jack
at 2010-05-21T18:27
at 2010-05-21T18:27

By Madame
at 2010-05-24T03:23
at 2010-05-24T03:23

By Sarah
at 2010-05-24T09:04
at 2010-05-24T09:04

By Connor
at 2010-05-25T09:31
at 2010-05-25T09:31

By Emily
at 2010-05-28T15:43
at 2010-05-28T15:43

By Enid
at 2010-05-30T21:35
at 2010-05-30T21:35

By Carol
at 2010-06-02T23:22
at 2010-06-02T23:22

By Olivia
at 2010-06-06T03:30
at 2010-06-06T03:30

By Leila
at 2010-06-10T09:11
at 2010-06-10T09:11

By Charlie
at 2010-06-14T19:21
at 2010-06-14T19:21

By Selena
at 2010-06-17T03:36
at 2010-06-17T03:36

By Damian
at 2010-06-19T13:40
at 2010-06-19T13:40

By Anonymous
at 2010-06-21T07:46
at 2010-06-21T07:46

By Jake
at 2010-06-24T11:50
at 2010-06-24T11:50

By Belly
at 2010-06-27T20:59
at 2010-06-27T20:59

By George
at 2010-07-01T18:02
at 2010-07-01T18:02

By Xanthe
at 2010-07-05T11:24
at 2010-07-05T11:24

By Jessica
at 2010-07-09T00:54
at 2010-07-09T00:54

By Xanthe
at 2010-07-12T17:26
at 2010-07-12T17:26

By Callum
at 2010-07-14T13:55
at 2010-07-14T13:55

By Aaliyah
at 2010-07-18T10:40
at 2010-07-18T10:40

By Charlie
at 2010-07-19T01:53
at 2010-07-19T01:53

By Harry
at 2010-07-20T07:55
at 2010-07-20T07:55

By Enid
at 2010-07-22T22:06
at 2010-07-22T22:06

By Bennie
at 2010-07-23T15:11
at 2010-07-23T15:11

By Irma
at 2010-07-27T17:45
at 2010-07-27T17:45

By Kumar
at 2010-07-31T23:07
at 2010-07-31T23:07

By Emma
at 2010-08-04T22:28
at 2010-08-04T22:28

By Elvira
at 2010-08-09T05:03
at 2010-08-09T05:03

By Irma
at 2010-08-10T15:25
at 2010-08-10T15:25

By Oscar
at 2010-08-12T15:22
at 2010-08-12T15:22

By Kyle
at 2010-08-14T08:54
at 2010-08-14T08:54

By Dorothy
at 2010-08-17T18:43
at 2010-08-17T18:43

By Iris
at 2010-08-21T00:50
at 2010-08-21T00:50

By Agnes
at 2010-08-23T05:47
at 2010-08-23T05:47

By Jake
at 2010-08-25T21:28
at 2010-08-25T21:28

By Hedy
at 2010-08-27T01:07
at 2010-08-27T01:07

By Joseph
at 2010-08-31T11:09
at 2010-08-31T11:09

By Olive
at 2010-09-01T01:03
at 2010-09-01T01:03

By Edwina
at 2010-09-05T09:15
at 2010-09-05T09:15

By Sierra Rose
at 2010-09-10T04:51
at 2010-09-10T04:51

By John
at 2010-09-14T04:35
at 2010-09-14T04:35

By Leila
at 2010-09-19T02:47
at 2010-09-19T02:47

By Leila
at 2010-09-19T12:26
at 2010-09-19T12:26

By Hamiltion
at 2010-09-23T08:50
at 2010-09-23T08:50

By Audriana
at 2010-09-27T18:03
at 2010-09-27T18:03

By Rosalind
at 2010-10-01T23:53
at 2010-10-01T23:53

By Daph Bay
at 2010-10-03T10:56
at 2010-10-03T10:56

By Heather
at 2010-10-07T22:41
at 2010-10-07T22:41

By Hedda
at 2010-10-10T14:30
at 2010-10-10T14:30

By Xanthe
at 2010-10-15T02:22
at 2010-10-15T02:22

By Oliver
at 2010-10-16T12:37
at 2010-10-16T12:37

By Edith
at 2010-10-18T22:01
at 2010-10-18T22:01

By Liam
at 2010-10-20T16:02
at 2010-10-20T16:02

By Quintina
at 2010-10-23T15:49
at 2010-10-23T15:49

By Kristin
at 2010-10-25T09:39
at 2010-10-25T09:39

By Gilbert
at 2010-10-29T17:21
at 2010-10-29T17:21

By Wallis
at 2010-11-01T12:15
at 2010-11-01T12:15

By Mason
at 2010-11-06T09:28
at 2010-11-06T09:28

By Doris
at 2010-11-07T04:26
at 2010-11-07T04:26

By Ophelia
at 2010-11-09T23:52
at 2010-11-09T23:52

By Rae
at 2010-11-11T23:27
at 2010-11-11T23:27

By Aaliyah
at 2010-11-12T00:49
at 2010-11-12T00:49

By Elma
at 2010-11-15T01:07
at 2010-11-15T01:07

By Enid
at 2010-11-15T10:29
at 2010-11-15T10:29

By Skylar Davis
at 2010-11-16T13:29
at 2010-11-16T13:29

By Jake
at 2010-11-19T04:57
at 2010-11-19T04:57

By Regina
at 2010-11-23T20:29
at 2010-11-23T20:29

By Daniel
at 2010-11-25T15:20
at 2010-11-25T15:20

By Catherine
at 2010-11-30T11:14
at 2010-11-30T11:14

By Bennie
at 2010-11-30T22:26
at 2010-11-30T22:26

By Linda
at 2010-12-02T21:33
at 2010-12-02T21:33

By Annie
at 2010-12-05T18:21
at 2010-12-05T18:21

By Daph Bay
at 2010-12-08T11:33
at 2010-12-08T11:33

By Catherine
at 2010-12-12T04:10
at 2010-12-12T04:10

By Irma
at 2010-12-14T06:04
at 2010-12-14T06:04

By Ina
at 2010-12-16T08:09
at 2010-12-16T08:09

By Hedda
at 2010-12-18T00:53
at 2010-12-18T00:53

By Brianna
at 2010-12-19T08:22
at 2010-12-19T08:22

By Callum
at 2010-12-20T19:22
at 2010-12-20T19:22

By Erin
at 2010-12-22T09:15
at 2010-12-22T09:15

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2010-12-22T22:14
at 2010-12-22T22:14

By Iris
at 2010-12-26T17:22
at 2010-12-26T17:22

By Todd Johnson
at 2010-12-30T19:43
at 2010-12-30T19:43

By Oliver
at 2011-01-03T14:03
at 2011-01-03T14:03

By Tracy
at 2011-01-06T21:14
at 2011-01-06T21:14

By Ula
at 2011-01-09T10:10
at 2011-01-09T10:10

By Agnes
at 2011-01-13T04:28
at 2011-01-13T04:28

By Jessica
at 2011-01-18T03:41
at 2011-01-18T03:41

By Queena
at 2011-01-20T19:55
at 2011-01-20T19:55

By Agatha
at 2011-01-23T17:37
at 2011-01-23T17:37

By Hardy
at 2011-01-25T18:21
at 2011-01-25T18:21

By Eartha
at 2011-01-27T12:19
at 2011-01-27T12:19

By Elvira
at 2011-02-01T00:41
at 2011-02-01T00:41

By Eden
at 2011-02-04T18:56
at 2011-02-04T18:56

By Leila
at 2011-02-08T12:40
at 2011-02-08T12:40

By Eden
at 2011-02-11T20:58
at 2011-02-11T20:58

By Wallis
at 2011-02-15T21:24
at 2011-02-15T21:24

By Michael
at 2011-02-18T03:02
at 2011-02-18T03:02

By Eartha
at 2011-02-22T04:13
at 2011-02-22T04:13

By Hardy
at 2011-02-26T06:20
at 2011-02-26T06:20

By Oliver
at 2011-02-28T20:18
at 2011-02-28T20:18

By Hedwig
at 2011-03-03T21:04
at 2011-03-03T21:04

By Harry
at 2011-03-08T06:26
at 2011-03-08T06:26

By Yuri
at 2011-03-09T06:07
at 2011-03-09T06:07

By Sandy
at 2011-03-10T23:58
at 2011-03-10T23:58

By Selena
at 2011-03-13T14:53
at 2011-03-13T14:53

By Carol
at 2011-03-17T02:50
at 2011-03-17T02:50

By Megan
at 2011-03-21T03:17
at 2011-03-21T03:17

By Valerie
at 2011-03-25T10:19
at 2011-03-25T10:19

By Andrew
at 2011-03-29T03:30
at 2011-03-29T03:30

By Elma
at 2011-04-01T14:54
at 2011-04-01T14:54

By Jacky
at 2011-04-02T00:27
at 2011-04-02T00:27

By Lydia
at 2011-04-02T07:07
at 2011-04-02T07:07

By Puput
at 2011-04-04T23:36
at 2011-04-04T23:36

By James
at 2011-04-07T12:38
at 2011-04-07T12:38

By Harry
at 2011-04-12T12:34
at 2011-04-12T12:34
Related Posts
熊26

By Wallis
at 2010-04-12T12:56
at 2010-04-12T12:56
真愛無國界 那家人呢?

By Catherine
at 2010-04-12T12:49
at 2010-04-12T12:49
關於這個版

By Vanessa
at 2010-04-12T12:22
at 2010-04-12T12:22
真愛無國界 那家人呢?

By George
at 2010-04-12T11:48
at 2010-04-12T11:48
小布

By Quanna
at 2010-04-12T11:13
at 2010-04-12T11:13